Thieves
854 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA
Rating: 4.5
Rated count: 182
Check on Google Maps
Discovering Thieves: A Hidden Gem in Broad Ripple
Nestled at 854 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220, Thieves is not just another bar; it’s an experience waiting to unfold. If you’re searching for the perfect spot to unwind after a long day or to kick-start your weekend adventures, Thieves stands out as an inviting destination that welcomes everyone with open arms.
Atmosphere: A Perfect Blend of Comfort and Intrigue
From the moment you step inside Thieves, the atmosphere wraps around you like a warm hug. The dim lighting creates an intimate vibe, ideal for catching up with friends or sharing a heartfelt conversation. Exposed brick walls adorned with eclectic artwork give the bar a charming, laid-back aesthetic. Vintage wooden tables and comfortable seating invite you to settle in and linger, making it clear that Thieves is a place designed for connection.
The bar has an undeniable energy—lively and upbeat, yet cozy enough for those quieter moments. The sound of laughter mingles with the clinking of glasses as patrons enjoy their favorite drinks. A carefully curated playlist adds to the ambiance, making you feel right at home while also keeping the mood just lively enough to enjoy a night out.
Why Visit Thieves?
For anyone exploring the Broad Ripple area and looking for a bar that offers much more than just drinks, Thieves is a fantastic choice. With an impressive selection of craft beers, inventive cocktails, and a menu full of delicious bites, there’s something for everyone here. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Thieves is the ideal spot to bring your friends together, meet new people, or even catch a game on one of their screens.
What to Expect
Given the intriguing name “Thieves,” you might wonder what kind of experience awaits you. Expect an ambiance that’s welcoming yet mysterious, perfect for those who enjoy a bit of playfulness with their evening out. The decor reflects this spirit—think charming treasures and quirky accents that make you feel like you’ve stumbled upon a secret hideout.
In terms of libations, you’ll find an impressive array of offerings, ranging from classic cocktails to unique concoctions inspired by seasonal ingredients. The bartenders are friendly and skilled, always ready to provide recommendations or whip up a drink tailored to your taste. If you’re feeling adventurous, ask about the “Thief’s Choice” where the bartender crafts something truly special just for you.
What’s more, Thieves often hosts events, from trivia nights to live music sessions, creating a dynamic environment that keeps the energy fresh. Check out their schedule—you might just find a themed night that piques your interest!
A Culinary Adventure
Beyond drinks, Thieves offers a menu that complements its bar vibe perfectly. Expect gourmet twists on classic pub fare—from mouthwatering sliders to artisanal flatbreads. The culinary team takes pride in using high-quality ingredients to craft dishes that are as delightful as the drinks they pair with. Vegetarian or gluten-free? You’ll find tasty options that ensure everyone can join the feast!
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re a die-hard local or just visiting, Thieves is certainly a bar you shouldn’t miss. It’s a blend of great drinks, mouthwatering food, and an atmosphere that’s both lively and cozy. The attention to detail in every aspect—from decor to service—makes it a standout spot on Broad Ripple Ave.
So, gather your friends, or bring your special someone, and head over to Thieves. Discover what it means to enjoy a night out at a bar that feels like home—but with a bit of intrigue and a lot of heart. You won’t just leave with a full belly; you’ll carry away a wonderful memory of time well spent. Cheers!
+1 248-762-9788
http://thievesindy.com/
Michelle Karam
March 25, 2026 at 9:55 pmI was in from out of town several days before Xmas, and was in the vicinity so from Googling, we ended up here for a quick and basic breakfast. We got basic croissant with egg and cheese buy still, I was impressed! Croissants tasted fresh. There were only a few other people there so I hope it makes more business because its a charming spot and is WOMAN OWNED! The atmosphere is that of a lounge, with several pretty red sofas.. and they’ve got a few of those popular lit up phrase-signs. It definitely has a different, more unique vibe than most places in Indy. Oh, and make sure you use the restroom, because the decor in there made me giggle out loud to myself!! There you’ll find the cat photos that I attached here!
Helpful ReviewNatalia Cruz
March 25, 2026 at 9:55 pmFirst time at new location, the service is the same high quality and the drinks still good. The vibes are similar, but this location is a lot brighter. Restrooms are nice and clean. Couches here are very cozy and I like the wired cellphone. One negative is that there is no longer outdoor setting.
Helpful ReviewGeorge Go
March 25, 2026 at 9:55 pmThe drinks were very good, and the waitress and bartenders were friendly and professional. However, the evening seemed to be affected by a staffing issue. On a busy, full-house night, there appeared to be only one server covering the floor while also assisting behind the bar. She was clearly working hard, but it took about 15 minutes just to place drink orders.
I also noticed several guests being turned away from the bar and told they needed to order through table service. This wasn’t something I experienced at the previous location, so it was a bit disappointing.
Overall, the staff did their best, and I’d consider returning during non-peak hours and hope to see improved staffing on busy nights.
Edit
Helpful ReviewIf you’re into smoked old fashions, beware that the ones here taste more tobacco-y compared to woody.
Jill Weiss
March 25, 2026 at 9:55 pmBest espresso martini. So balanced and you can actually taste a great, rich espresso. The espresso martini is not usually my jam because they’re often too sweet or full of cream. But Thieves’ version is clean, bold, and tasty. Seasonal cocktails were flavorful and fun as well. And it’s a cool atmosphere with a little edge.
Helpful ReviewJessica Nettgen
March 25, 2026 at 9:55 pmSuch an adorable quaint cocktail bar! We came from out of town and the bartender gave us lots of good recommendations for this trip & beyond. She was awesome and continued to chat with us while she was closing up. Great drinks, great vibes, would totally go again!
Helpful Review